Skip to main content

Summary of ‘A Case of Identity’ by Arthur Conan Doyle (⩽500 words)

 

Author: Arthur Conan Doyle

Boy oh boy! The plot of this one has inspired very many movies, TV series, etc. across the globe. The motive was to save the pension of £100 a year for himself which actually belonged to the step-daughter and would be entitled to her husband once she was married. The stepfather, Mr Windibank, created this web of lies in coalition with the girl’s biological mother. He pretended to be someone, Mr Hosmer Angel, who had fallen for the girl and left her at the gate of the church on the wedding day all while he made her pledge allegiance to him despite of him being away for indefinite time. But the whole scenario landed her in Sherlock’s lodging at Baker Street. The girl got Sherlock’s reference from a lady whose husband was found by Sherlock in no time while everyone else had given up. Sherlock noticed she was nearsighted and a typist from the first glance at her. Her being nearsighted made way for her mother and stepfather to mingle her with a figment of imagination who left her at the altar. While it was perplexing for Dr Watson, Sherlock seemed to be quite eased and relaxed through the whole incidence. He examined the evidence and concluded that the stepfather was indeed the love interest of the daughter with the motive being solemnly financial. Interesting piece of evidence was the typewritten letters. Since the letters were typed using the same typewriter by the stepfather and the Hosmer, they showed similarities in the erring of certain alphabets and 14 other such peculiarities. The man when confronted by Sherlock was trying his best to escape in every manner possible viz. accusing Sherlock of assault and constraining for the act that Sherlock locked door to stop him from running away. This elicited a rather sentimental response from Sherlock, which in all its true meaning is rare for Sherlock. However, Sherlock had right away assured her to forget the man of her dreams during their first meeting. This shows the brilliance and imagination of Arthur. He indeed was an author way ahead of his times. There are certain sentences I would like to mention here which have great impact on me. “life is infinitely stranger than anything which the mind of man could invent” Sherlock to Dr Watson. “I have found that it is usually in unimportant matters that there is a field for the observation, and for the quick analysis of cause and effect which gives the charm to an investigation. The larger crimes are apt to be the simpler, for the bigger the crime the more obvious, as a rule, is the motive.” Sherlock to Dr Watson. Arthur has signified these line here by example. While everyone was perplexed how the man escaped the wagon while everyone saw him board it, the way Hosmer disguised and acted around her and how Hosmer & the stepfather were never seen together led to a simple deduction that both are the same person.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Summary of ‘The Red-Headed League’ by Arthur Conan Doyle (⩽500 words)

  Author: Arthur Conan Doyle   A very classic plot for bank robberies across ages for real as well as in dramas and movies. Very elaborate plot strategized with mastery by the infamous John Clay with whom Sherlock had had encounters but never came face to face. The bank of London had acquired French gold and quite a bulk of it. They stored it in the basement i.e. the strong vault of the bank. John Clay assumed a fake identity and took the job at the shop adjacent to the bank at half the salary. He presented to the owner that photography is a hobby of his and spent hours in the cellar developing his pictures. Later he guided the owner to an interview published in the newspaper for the Red-Headed League as he had ginger hair. And amongst a healthy crowd the owner got selected for the position. All he had to do was make copy of encyclopedia for 4 hours every day for a compensation of 4 pounds per week. The only condition was he cannot leave the room even onc...

Summary of ‘He said it with Arsenic’ by Ruskin Bond (⩽500 words)

  Author: Ruskin Bond   The story starts with a riveting question “Is there such a person as born murderer?” As chilling as the title, the first line sets the stage for what is to come ahead. The story is from first person perspective. It refers to the infamous Agra Double Murder in the beginning. Though I found out there is a novel by same name after reading this story I am trying to summarize this story which may have been influenced from the novel. Ruskin Bond, a name almost every Indian is familiar with is a wizard of words. The story is about William Jones, a male nurse by profession and his actions. Bored from an unhappy marriage he instantly fell for Mrs. Browning, stationmaster’s wife. They communicated via letters and over time those letters grew heavier as the envelops carried a white powder in them. Soon after the station master started keeping ill. His stay at the hospital would clear his system up but as soon as he returned home, he met the s...

Hazrat Amir Khusrau – Part 04

  Note: This is the Hazrat Amir Khusrau series where I try and interpret the meaning of the poem “Chaap Tilak” in simple words with whatever little understanding of the world and experience of Life I have.     The lines I’ll try and interpret today are as follows.   बल बल जाऊं मैं तोरे रंग रजवा अपनी सी रंग दीनी रे मोसे नैना मिलाइके   Literal translation – I give you my life O my beloved, you have painted me in your colours with a single glance. What is left of the person when all his/her signs, symbols, attachments and identity are stripped away? A person transforms into something like an empty pot somewhat like the blank canvas of a painter ready to be developed into a masterpiece by the painter. The disciple has unlearnt whatever he/she has acquired during a life time and ready to receive something new what the mentor has to offer. And just as effortlessly the mentor made the disciple forget the learnings, he is ...